Tech Underground Railroad: Why we should help migrants escape slavery
Figure 1: "I grew up like a neglected weed - ignorant of liberty, having no experience of it." – Harriet Tubman
This week I helped break one more person free of Microsoft. These are the feelings it brought up for me about the gargantuan task ahead for all of us.
Fleeing familiar comfort takes courage. It is the courage to pass through some internal threshold of quiet toleration. That's the moment we become migrants, or escapees. The remaining journey, however arduous, is epilogue. Migration occurs in a single moment of choice. Whether it's escaping an abusive relationship or moving from the ruins of a war-torn city, the equation is the same.
Some part of us is attached and invested in remaining. We mistake it for loyalty. We hope that things can turn around for the better. We can rebuild our home. We can make change from within. Fortunes will be restored. Perhaps what we love can "be saved". Another part of us longs for a different future, any future, to leave everything we have behind and move on. There are people we might have to leave behind, like family who cannot make the change. There are always threats of violence from those who imprison us, barriers to movement, gatekeepers who must be paid, authorities who must be assuaged, tricked or overcome. One day comes the sad realisation that "home" is no longer home. Escape is the life ahead for us. It is terrifying and yet hopeful.
Living by the coast I sometimes saw smugglers. As a teenager at a late night beach party on a remote part of the Dorset coast, I once saw a RIB silently come ashore and signal to a landrover parked in the woods. Now, it may well have been our venerable SBS fellas in some sort of training exercise, but three o'clock in the morning is not the best time or situation to wander over and ask some chaps in balaclavas what's in those crates they're unloading. Now, as we were walking on the beach recently, my wife and I pondered what we'd do if a similar boat, this time filled with hungry and frightened people, washed up on our shore. Would we call the police? Or would we try to help with hot soup, blankets, finding a translator and perhaps a lawyer? Would we offer the children a spare room? In short, would we reach out and help people who have lost everything but the clothes they wear? Would we risk retribution from the local neo-Nazis for playing the good Samaritan?
In the case of actual migrants needing help, I'd probably do what what most of my fellow Englishmen would, ignore it, rationalise, and pretend it isn't happening. I'd go home and say "Honey, I saw the strangest thing at the beach today. A boat-load of starving people washed up! I'm sure they'll be fine". My question in other words is, in these times so reminiscent of the 1930's, what might each of us do to help? To help because it is the right thing to do? A popular saying in Britain, where many people are ambivalent about charity, activism, or even just doing the right thing, is "No good deed goes unpunished." However, when I was once working on documentation related to the "PREVENT" initiative (counter-radicalisation in the UK), I stumbled upon a strange file containing a (since removed) list of "British Values" penned by the then Home Secretary. That list included;
- A sense of fair play
- championing the underdog
So, what sort of British person are you?
In my comfortable everyday life I meet dozens of potential tech refugees. Certainly there are people who would like to physically emigrate from the United States, to become European computer scientists and developers, but I am talking about those who want to make the digital jump. They're all stuck using technology that is abusive, corrosive and treacherous. They are users of US American Big Tech; things like Facebook, Instagram, Google and Microsoft. Many of them are at their wits end, frustrated by inner conflict.
I generally spot them easily. They make cloaked overtures as soon as they see my mail signature, when I tell them I don't use Microsoft services, or if I ask "please send me a plain-text option not filled with proprietary malware". They half apologise for their digital affiliations and not "being able" - but at the same time are pointedly nudging me to throw them some hope.
The world has changed since the 1990s when geeky people like myself just helped out people with their tech because it made us feel useful.
Fact is, helping them costs me and exposes me to risk, so I have to be careful and choosy. Many people ask for help, and then get cold feet, back-out, and even blame their helper for having "tried to seduce them". Stockholm syndrome is rife around digital tech users. This week I helped another one. It always feels like going out on a limb. Will they make it? Or will they be back on US tech in a few months like a relapsed heroin addict, with our friendship soured by a silent guilt?
These are people fed up with being spied on, dicked around, having their private affairs rifled through, used against them. They are furious at the total lack of ethics of companies like Google or Amazon, who are now indisputably a new locus of evil like tobacco and oil companies. They are deeply concerned about the safety of their own data and the continuity of services they rely on for daily life and business. They are worried about the political ties of US technofascists to Trump, Putin and other authoritarians.
Also they are astonished that our government has done abolutely nothing and offers not even a hint of leadership in the technological world. Aside from a few rather timid and ineffectual leaflets made by our NCSC, government is utterly lost in challenging the bare-faced and entitled criminal abuses of digital technology firms.
They want out. Not being "Luddites" they realise as in the Soviet Era, that there's a better land beyond their "mental borders". They do not want to withdraw into technological isolation, but to seek out a promised land of digital freedom. They have heard about Software Freedom and the world of open source.
Sadly, most of them are doomed. The only exposure to news and personal communication they have is from within systems that are owned and controlled by their abusers. Half the world gets its news from Facebook. For them, messages of hope never arrive. Or they are drowned out by the lies about "risks" of alternative software and technology. Many of these lies are echoed by the mainstream media and governments who are in the pockets of foreign tech businesses.
As in the Truman Show, or Kafka's Trial all attempts they make to leave lead back to the pastures of digital domestication… where things "are safe". US companies like Facebook spend billions on disinformation to influence users not to leave and to discredit alternatives that give users real control back. They sow fear, uncertainty and doubt in the minds of their addicted captives.
Besides, many if not most are not ready to make the journey. There is still too much fear and ambivalence. They are too weak to overcome the propaganda that keeps them in place. "What will happen to my network of friends or followers?", "How can I move my files, photos, and emails?". "What about my bookmarks?". Some of these are genuine concerns. US Big Tech companies have always treated their users as prisoners and been fined billions to enforce interoperability and data migration rules. Still, they make it as hard as humanly possible to migrate. Fancy theories of "network effects" are proffered to explain "frozen herd behaviour", but as we all know in our hearts it is fear that keeps people from moving.
And some of that fear is justified. Let me be honest with you: Getting free of Big Tech is not an easy ride. But it is doable. My intro about refugees crossing in small boats is not a ridiculous metaphor. It's hazardous, and some of you will fall over the side and be eaten by sharks. You will lose some contacts and connection with some friends, unless you are prepared to take active (inconvenient) steps to make other arrangements, call people by telephone, use email from a new account. Ironically, this may be the first meaningful (non passive) communication you'll have had with them in years. You may lose data unless you take great care. You will be punished, directly and indirectly by the powerful monopoly tech-gangsters that currently own your life. You will be victimised and marginalised, perhaps by your employer, in workplaces and corporate power centres controlled by US Big tech interests. The UK is still a vassal state to such foreign interests.
Nobody is offering you a relocation package with first-class flight and five-star hotel room. This is a midnight border crossing into the unknown. But doesn't that excite and intrigue you? Not even a little?
There are very few high-street shops of any kind left in Britain thanks to Amazon, and even if there were, very few can offer you an update to Linux from Windows for your PC.
Even though it is a skill no harder than for a mechanic replacing spark-plugs or brake-pads in a car, there are almost no stores with engineers that can fully de-Google a phone or tablet and replace it with an operating system that doesn't spy on you. Given the enormous demand, this refutes of the fantasy of market economics. The story we are repeatedly sold is that people are happy in their slavery. Presumably when the shelves are bare in supermarkets, people are happy with their diets, because they are not buying food?
The FSF and other organisations for software freedom are missing something. They are entrenched in the American delusion of free-choice and the idea that software is "a market". It is not. The problem is not that people "must be forced to be free", as Sartre or Rousseau opined, but that they must be shown the path freedom as Harriet Tubman and others laboured to do.
Free Open Source Software is finding it needs something akin to "The Underground Railroad". In the 1800s Harriet Tubman was an devoted abolitionist who fought slavery and forced labour. She helped organise networks of secret escape routes, safe houses, maps, contact lists, transport and food supplies. She worked like the French SOE operatives helping people escape the Nazis in WW2.
When it comes to tech, there are people like us out there that can help you. We have networks. We have tools. We have tried and tested methods. We have friends everywhere. But you need to find us. And you need to convince us that you are ready… not just to make the crossing but to become an ally and fellow helper once you reach freedom, because there's still not enough of us to help everyone.
For my troubles my refugee bought me a nice Chinese takeaway and some beers. While we were having a pint at the local pub, he let lose on the truth about his feelings for America, for its tech industry and deep beliefs about getting shut of all of it. He'd spent a lifetime as an institutional insider in a country whose government still sucks up to Microsoft, Amazon and Google. I had still not fully wiped Microsoft Windows from his system, but already I could see a burden lifting from his shoulders and a smile returning to his face.
Fortunately, as I said, he's someone who had already made the choice long ago, done the research and realised that LibreOffice and everything else he wanted would suffice on Linux. Today I'm nervous because I haven't heard from him about how he's doing with a fresh Debian 13 KDE install. In all the migration took five or six hours. Most of that was backing up 200GB of family data, a job that really needed doing anyway. A little of the time was teaching him to re-orient with new desktop, but nowadays Linux is simply a compatible but superior desktop experience out of the box. We've still work to do pulling down everything from Microsoft and Google cloud services and storing it locally in duplicate on several 1TB hard drives. The move to Proton or NextCloud is planned for email. I still have to show him IMAP tricks to migrate mailboxes. Next comes de-Googling the phones and tablets.
One experience still haunts me. It wasn't a clean wipe that could be done entirely from a Live USB Install. Because some files needed extracting from the existing Windows system I had to sit at a Windows 11 desktop for a while. I was shocked. As someone who avoids Microsoft at all costs I was unaware how much further the experience had degraded. Advertisements randomly popped up. The whole Windows 11 desktop is a circus of media pushing rage-bait, and constant intrusions. It was like a trip to a shopping mall just before Christmas. I felt physically disturbed by the exposure.
On the whole though, the migration is working out for my escapee. That's one technology user who is never going back to using US American tech. Yet it occurs to me that Individual Digital Sovereignty and Civic Cyber Security are projects that cannot be industrialised. They are mass social movements that must be cultivated bottom-up like a civil militia, home guard or Dig For Victory type affair. Like in the 1990s when everybody knew a "computer guy", we'll need thousands of digital ambassadors and local guides to get Britain free of the Yankee yoke.
For decades, companies like Google, Microsoft, and Meta have dominated our world with their piss-poor quality, insecure and treacherous products. Few people have ever known about the alternatives; about reliability, freedom, real self-ownership and control. More and more people are hearing about the path to Software Freedom and making the change. This is good for everyone in Britain and Europe. However, the chances that the British government will ever offer any money or help, or treat civic cybersecurity seriously, seem infinitesimal. Responsibility therefore falls on the individual citizen with "British Values" to do the right thing and help out your fellows.
Help a friend see more clearly. Wipe a Windows today!
